Horror & Monster Puzzles
Best Selling
SPONSOREDSPONSOREDSPONSOREDSPONSOREDSPONSOREDSPONSORED
664 Results
RARE WHITMAN - DARK SHADOWS - GRAVEYARD - 1200 Piece JIGSAW PUZZLE #4869
$27.770 bids$10.80 shippingEnding May 20 at 12:13PM PDT3d 18h1969 vintage Dark Shadows Jigsaw Puzzle in original box, Barnabus Collins
$54.99$10.80 shipping500 Pc Puzzle Adult Halloween Witch Haunted House New
$12.00or Best Offer$7.00 shippingKing Kong Vintage Puzzle 1976 by HG in Box! Excellent Condition & Complete!
$14.95$6.95 shippingHalloween Horror Movie Character Collage 1000 Piece Basswood Puzzle With Poster!
$29.99or Best Offer$6.00 shippingVintage Creepy Magazine Cover 71 Puzzle 1975 Ken Kelly Dungeons & Dragons MB
$45.00$10.80 shippingDRACULA - 1000 PIECE PREMIUM PUZZLE - FRANCAVILLA x MONDO (New & Sealed)
$24.95or Best OfferFree shippingVtg Goosebumps Scarecrow Walks Midnight Puzzle COMPLETE and family DVD Game
$20.47Was: $23.00or Best OfferFree shippingJudy instructo VTG wooden puzzle
$19.00or Best Offer$6.72 shippingPIECES -1000 Piece Horror Jigsaw Puzzle (Messed Up Puzzles)
$30.00$9.00 shippingVintage 1977 Creepy Magazine Puzzle 4777-2 Milton Bradley 500 Series
$49.99$12.50 shippingREVENGE of the CREATURE Mondo 1000piece Puzzle Universal Monster Francavilla NEW
$25.00$10.50 shipping1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzles Animals Landmarks - LOTS OF DESIGNS TO CHOOSE FROM
$10.06$8.84 shippingVintage 1973 Springbok Hallmark Puzzle House On Haunted Hill Halloween Complete
$87.99or Best Offer$7.00 shipping13 watchingOOP! RARE! ELVIRA #6 -2000 Piece Horror Jigsaw Puzzle (Messed Up Puzzles)
$50.00$9.00 shippingDRACULA’S CASTLE BURIED BLUEPRINTS Puzzles From The Past 1000 Pieces
$15.000 bids$6.02 shippingEnding May 19 at 5:50AM PDT2d 12hHammer Films Horror 1000-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Aquarius Brand New Sealed
$19.99or Best OfferFree shippingNEW Halloween Puzzle 300 Piece On a Spooky Night 18" x 24" Factory sealed
$12.75or Best Offer$9.25 shippingHALLOWEEN HORROR CLASSIC 1000pc Puzzle..SEALED/NEW
$14.99$8.00 shippingCreature From The Black Lagoon 200 Piece 1990 Golden Puzzle Universal Monsters
$17.95Was: $19.95or Best OfferFree shippingSpringbok House On Haunted Hill Puzzle Complete w/ Box, 100 pc. Vintage 1973
$111.99Free shippingALIEN ~ Giant Jigsaw 250 Piece Puzzle (36"X14") - 1979 VTG RARE, COMPLETE!!!
$119.95or Best Offer$7.16 shippingHeye - Zozoville Monsta Hi! 1000 Piece Puzzle
$29.99Free shipping7 watchingPomegranate Edward Gorey Dracula in Dr Seward's Library Complete 500 pc Puzzle!!
$6.490 bids$11.40 shippingEnding Friday at 6:51PM PDT1d 1hGREMLINS Jigsaw Puzzle 500 Pieces Horror NMR Gizmo Stripe Mogwai New
$9.99$10.80 shippingGoosebumps Puzzle 200 Piece Complete Slappy Horror Land Glow In The Dark MB
$60.05or Best Offer$12.50 shippingCREATURE BLACK LAGOON Jigsaw puzzle classic monster horror movie gillman
$24.97$3.99 shipping23 watchingThe Evil Dead -1000 Piece Horror Jigsaw Puzzle (Messed Up Puzzles) #4
$25.00$9.00 shippingUniversal Studios Monsters The Dracula Ja-Ru Slide Puzzle
$15.29or Best Offer$8.00 shippingSUSPIRIA -1000 Piece Horror Jigsaw Puzzle (Messed Up Puzzles) - Dario Argento
$25.00$9.00 shippingAPC Frankenstein Jigsaw Puzzle # 1181/Vintage 1974
$44.95or Best Offer$8.95 shipping"Reaper Beach" 500 Piece Multicolor Jigsaw Puzzle Spencer's 20" x 28" New
$26.99Was: $29.99or Best Offer$12.45 shippingGoosebumps Puzzle Glow In The Dark MB 200 Pc Complete Slappy Horror Land
$52.24or Best Offer$14.50 shippingCannibal Holocaust 'B' -1000 Piece Horror Jigsaw Puzzle (Messed Up Puzzles)
$30.00$9.00 shippingVintage Springbok MONSTER MAZE Childrens 100 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Halloween Game
$49.95or Best Offer$11.60 shippingDISNEYLAND HAUNTED MANSION 4 PUZZLE SET-500 pc each-Stretching Portraits
$24.990 bids$13.93 shippingEnding Saturday at 5:00PM PDT1d 23hGOOSEBUMPS MB 100 Piece Puzzle GHOST CAMP #45 Complete Rare 1996 VIntage 12.5x15
$19.95or Best Offer$9.95 shippingT-Rex Selfies Prime 3d Puzzle 150 Pieces 46x 31cm 18x12 In
$11.99or Best OfferFree shippingClementoni Horror Gallery Fluorescent Puzzle Dracula
$31.49Was: $44.99or Best Offer$9.21 shipping1974 H-G Toys Creepy Creatures Egyptian Mummy Puzzle w/ Box Complete!
$54.99or Best Offer$9.95 shippingThe Creature From The Black Lagoon 200 Piece Puzzle Golden 1990
$12.99$6.26 shippingEurographics 550 piece Puzzle Halloween Barn with Tin and Poster
$13.50Was: $15.00or Best Offer$9.47 shippingHaunted Halloween Village 300 Piece Bits And Pieces Puzzle
$20.00Free shippingVintage sealed 1993 The Addams Family Jigsaw Puzzle by Golden
$29.99or Best Offer$7.00 shippingFuggler Funny Ugly Monster 100 Piece Puzzle Orange #20107049 Cardinal NEW
$10.00Free shippingShaped Puzzle Kathy Jakobsen Boo Haunted House 750 PCs Halloween NEW
$19.99$11.60 shippingThe Executioner An Easy To Assemble Moving Model
$9.990 bids$6.00 shippingEnding Today at 5:33PM PDT1m 45sSealed Horror Scary Movie Collage 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle 70cm x 50cm DCBA HGFE
$15.00$9.02 shippingThe World of Frankenstein 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle - 100% Complete, EX Condition
$22.95or Best OfferFree shippingNew MFM My Favorite Murder 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle True Crime Podcast Locations
$40.00$10.80 shipping1999 The Gruglin Gutz Jigsaw Puzzles Kid’s. Vintage 90’s Toy. Y2K.
$13.50or Best Offer$10.80 shippingCREEPSHOW 1000 Piece Horror Jigsaw Puzzle (Messed Up Puzzles) Stephen King
$30.00$9.00 shippingOOP! Rare! ELVIRA #2 -1000 Piece Horror Jigsaw Puzzle (Messed Up Puzzles)
$100.00$9.00 shipping